|
THE MAGEPAGE
|
January 2001
|
|
Strategic Statements
- Tools for Entrepreneurs
|
|
|
From Jeffrey Davis' Desk...
Everyone is asking us, is the economy changing? It appears
that the growth rate is leveling off; and we are in a transition.
What remains in question is which companies are heading for
a soft landing or a more abrupt and disruptive slow down.
The challenge for owners is to grow the business and take
advantage of an uncertainty in the economy. Senior Consultant
Stephen Kotler addresses a key skill necessary for ensuring
continued growth that is often ignored by entrepreneurs: Financial
Analysis. A properly designed accounting system facilitates
an owner's ability to analyze company performance and plan
for the future. Steve reviews the foundations and uses for
Financial Analysis in this month's issue.
I want to wish all of Mage's friends and associates the best
of luck as we face new challenges and opportunities in the
new millennium.
Jeffrey S Davis
Chairman and CEO
STRATEGIC STATEMENTS
Tools for Entrepreneurs
Business today faces a growing sense of uncertainty.
The stock market has declined amidst fears of earnings warnings
and downgrades while all indicators show signs of a changing
economy. Sales growth rates are declining as consumers and
customers fear an economic slowdown. This economic environment
has put pressure on entrepreneurs and business owners to ensure
their businesses continue to grow and prosper. Strategic navigation
through periods of economic uncertainty requires that management
fully understand its business and performance. Leaders who
possess the ability to analyze and interpret their company's
financial performance have a roadmap for making business decisions
that can ensure profitability and growth in the most challenging
of times.
Entrepreneurs frequently need to answer critical
issues such as: Why has my business been successful? Why is
my business unprofitable despite continued sales growth? Why
does my business always seem to be operating in a cash crunch?
Entrepreneurs can answer these critical strategic questions
by obtaining accurate and timely financial reports and by
performing an analysis using basic financial planning models.
Entrepreneurs predominantly face five major
issues in the managing of their business: Profitability -
Is the company making money? Cash Flow - Does the company
generate enough cash to cover operational needs? 3. Performance
- Does the company use budgets and forecasts to benchmark
performance and achieve its goals and objectives? 4. Undercapitalization
- Does the company have enough capital to operate effectively?
5. Growth - What rate and type of growth is most beneficial
to the company?
Numerous methods exist that enable entrepreneurs
and business owners to evaluate performance by comparing current
financial statistics to historical and competitive benchmarks.
The most useful tools include:
- Ratio Analysis
- Comparative Analysis
- Percentage Analysis
Ratio Analysis Ratio: Analysis involves the calculation
of ratios utilizing figures on the Balance Sheet and Income
Statement to evaluate the performance of a company.
Liquidity Ratios: Liquidity Ratios gauge a business's
ability to pay its short-term obligations with its short-term
assets. The most common ratios include the Current Ratio or
Working Capital Ratio (Current Assets divided by Current Liabilities)
and the Quick Ratio or Acid Test Ratio (Cash + Short-term
investments + Accounts Receivable less than 90 days divided
by Current Liabilities). Generally, a Current Ratio greater
than 1:1 and a Quick Ratio greater than 0.5:1 indicate that
a company is sufficiently liquid to continue operating.
Activity Ratios: Activity ratios indicate how effectively
a company is managing its assets. The most common ratios include
Accounts Receivable Turnover (Net Sales divided by Average
Accounts Receivable), Accounts Receivable Collection Period
(365 divided by Accounts Receivable Turnover), Inventory Turnover
(Cost of Goods Sold divided by Average Inventory), Days Inventory
on Hand (365 divided by Inventory Turnover), and Operating
Cycle (Accounts Receivable Collection Period + Days Inventory
on Hand). These ratios are measured in 'turns', i.e. the number
of times the asset has been collected or sold in a period,
or 'days' i.e. the number of days needed to collect or sell
the asset. Generally, higher turnover rates and lower collection
periods or days inventory on hand indicate higher quality
assets that are more readily convertible into cash to sustain
the company.
Profitability Ratios: Profitability Ratios measure
the degree of success of a business over time. The most common
ratios include Gross Profit Ratio (Gross Profit divided by
Net Sales) or remainder of sales after the associated costs
of those sales has been deducted; Return on Equity (Net Earnings
divided by Average Common Equity) or rate of return on equity
invested in the business; and Return on Assets (Net Earnings
divided by Average Total Assets) or rate of return on assets
employed in operating the business. Generally, larger percentages
imply a more profitable business.
Coverage Ratios: Coverage ratios indicate the degree
of protection that creditors and investors hold in a business,
and provide information on how much financial leverage (debt)
may be used by the company. The most common ratios include
Debt to Equity Ratio (Total Debt divided by Total Equity),
and Debt to Assets (Total Liabilities divided by Total Assets).
Generally, ratios of 1:1 or less indicate that a company does
not use a disproportionate amount of debt to finance its operations,
and that future growth can be achieved by borrowing additional
money. Other ratios include Times Interest Earned (Earnings
Before Interest and Taxes divided by Interest Expense), Book
Value per Share (Shareholders' Equity divided by Common Shares
Outstanding), and Cash Flow per Share (Cash Flow from Operations
divided by Common Shares Outstanding). Generally, larger ratios
indicate the ability of the company to generate earnings and
cash flow to finance current operations and fund future growth
and expansion.
Limitations: Ratios are widely used by managers, creditors
and investors. Used correctly, ratios can tell a lot about
a company and its operations. However, ratios are just one
number divided by another, so it is difficult to imagine that
these numbers can accurately reflect the full picture of something
as complex as a modern corporation. No one ratio itself will
paint a true financial picture of the company. For example
profitability ratios like Return on Equity (ROE) say nothing
about the risks a company has taken to generate it. Because
ROE looks only at the return while ignoring risk, it can be
an inaccurate yardstick of financial performance.
Analysis using a combination of ratios will lead to more
valid strategic decisions. It is useful to think of ratios
as pieces to the puzzle that forms your business. One or several
pieces might not seem to fit at first but when combined with
other knowledge of a company's management and economic circumstances,
ratios can tell a revealing story.
Another point to remember is that a ratio has no single correct
value. The observation that a company's particular ratio is
too high, too low or just right depends on the perspective
of the analyst reviewing the data. For example from the perspective
of a short term creditor, a high current ratio is a positive
sign because it shows that the company has the ability to
pay its obligations. Yet the owner of the firm may see this
as a negative sign that the company's assets are being deployed
too conservatively. The important point here is not whether
or not the current ratio is too high but whether the chosen
strategy is the best one for the company under consideration.
As with any other financial data, the quality of financial
ratios is dependent on the quality of the numbers they are
derived from. Keep in mind that financial information is based
on historical costs, and does not reflect the impact of non-financial
determinants such as inflation, competition and technology.
Comparative Analysis: Comparative Analysis or Horizontal
Analysis examines the proportion of change in Income Statement
items over a period time, usually years, allowing analysts
to draw firmer conclusions about the firm's financial health.
Trends are usually compared between more than one item since
interrelationships exist between Income Statement items. For
example, a comparison of Sales and Gross Profit dollars and
growth rates over time may indicate whether additional sales
from new products or services are generating additional profit.
It is also very useful to compare ratios calculated to those
from outside sources including banking and finance publications
(Dun and Bradstreet, Moody's, Standard and Poor's or Robert
Morris Associates), government agencies (Department of Commerce
or OSHA), as well as industry trade groups or associations
that regularly survey their members for 'State of the Industry'
analysis. Information from these sources can be used as a
benchmark to gauge the performance of a company against its
competitors. It is important to note that company specific
differences can result in justifiable deviations from industry
norms.
Percentage Analysis: Percentage Analysis or Vertical
Analysis entails the comparison of one item relative to a
base item on the Income Statement. The most commonly used
base item is Net Sales. For example, Cost of Goods Sold, Sales
and Marketing expenses and General and Administrative expenses
are frequently calculated as a percentage of Net Sales. Analyzing
these percentages using Comparative Analysis provides additional
information on how these expenses vary over time as well.
Other Tips: Entrepreneurs typically focus on the Income
Statement to evaluate how they are managing their business.
In most situations, the Cost of Goods Sold is the largest
expense on this statement, and as such, deserves a lot of
attention. Focus should be placed on items that directly affect
production costs. Savings of even a small percentage in Cost
of Goods Sold will translate into a dramatic increase in your
bottom line. It is equally important to focus the Balance
Sheet since it indicates the financial health of the company.
An executive is like the captain of a ship, without good
financial statements and the thoughtful analyses you will
never navigate your company through the next big storm. By
comparing your company's ratios to rules of thumb, industry
averages and changes over time you will have the ability to
run a successful business during the most difficult of times.
Stephen Kotler, CA, CPA
Senior Consultant
Mage, LLC
|